In business circles, there’s a recurring debate: Are strategy and planning the same thing? Should we even talk about “strategic planning”?
Some argue the terms are contradictory. Others suggest the difference is academic.
But at the heart of the matter is a simple truth: clarity matters—and so does coherence.
Let’s unpack the issue and explore why understanding the relationship between strategy and planning is not just helpful, but essential to effective execution and long-term success.
🔍 Strategy vs Planning: What’s the Difference?
The distinction between strategy and planning is both real and useful—when correctly understood.
| Purpose | Decide what matters most | Operationalise what matters most |
| Key Question | “What should we do, and why?” | “How do we get it done?” |
| Time Horizon | Long-term, directional | Short- to medium-term, executable |
| Nature | Adaptive, conceptual | Structured, procedural |
| Focus | Positioning, trade-offs, advantage | Resources, timing, coordination |
Strategy is about choosing where and how to compete.
Planning is about turning that intent into coordinated action.
Both are essential—but they’re not interchangeable.
❌ When Strategy and Planning Are Confused
In many organisations, strategic planning has become synonymous with producing a lengthy document full of charts, forecasts, and goals—but lacking true strategic insight. This leads to:
-
Plans that don’t make real choices
-
Strategies that aren’t resourced or actionable
-
Confused teams and misaligned execution
As one user insightfully observed:
“If your strategy says one thing and your plan says another, then either one or the other won’t get done.”
That’s spot on. Misalignment creates strategic drift, where the organisation says one thing but does another—leading to underperformance or even outright failure.
✅ Why the Distinction Is Helpful
Far from being academic, separating strategy and planning helps organisations:
-
Avoid conflating vision with activity
-
Encourage deep thinking before committing resources
-
Navigate uncertainty with adaptability
-
Create focus by making real trade-offs
-
Drive alignment across departments and teams
However, this distinction must not become a division. The two disciplines must be closely connected—each informing and sharpening the other.
🔄 Can Planning Shape Strategy?
Absolutely.
While strategy traditionally precedes planning, in practice:
-
Planning reveals constraints that challenge strategic assumptions
-
Operational realities surface during planning that reshape strategic direction
-
Cross-functional engagement in planning highlights gaps in capabilities, coordination, or incentives
-
Scenario planning and modelling expose fragility in strategy and encourage robust design
In short, planning is not just downstream of strategy—it’s a feedback loop that refines and tests strategic choices.
🤔 Is the Problem Really with "Strategic Planning"?
Many critics argue that “strategic planning shouldn’t be a thing.” But what they’re really opposing is doing it badly, especially when:
-
It becomes an annual bureaucratic ritual
-
It avoids difficult trade-offs
-
It focuses on continuity, not advantage
-
It’s disconnected from execution
The problem isn’t the concept of strategic planning—it’s the quality and intent of the process.
Done well, strategic planning is:
-
A disciplined dialogue about direction and priorities
-
A way to align vision with resource allocation
-
A mechanism to ensure strategy lives in decisions, not just documents
Why you can't separate them
Strategy and planning are inseparable. Here is why:
One without the other is useless:
- A strategy without a plan that delivers it is merely a vain hope.
- A plan without a strategy to guide it is merely busy work.
You need both. Moreover, you need them to align.
If your strategy says one thing—e.g., “We’re going to differentiate through innovation”—but your plan says another—e.g., “We’re cutting R&D and prioritising efficiency”—then:
-
Either the strategy is hollow (not backed by action),
-
Or the plan is misguided (ignores strategic intent).
In both cases, you won’t get what you say you want.
Doing strategy without planning is as useless as doing planning without strategy. The only solution is to do strategic planning in a way that combines both.
🎯 What Really Matters: Strategic Coherence
Ultimately, the goal is not to merge strategy and planning into a single idea, but to make them coherent and mutually reinforcing.
“Strategy sets the destination and rationale;
Planning maps the route and coordinates the journey.”
When done right, they:
-
Speak with one voice
-
Align across functions and levels
-
Create confidence in both direction and delivery
📌 Final Thought
Understanding the difference between strategy and planning isn’t pedantry—it’s precision. It enables clarity of purpose, coherence of action, and ultimately, competitive advantage.
Rather than rejecting strategic planning, we should reclaim and reform it—to ensure it serves its true purpose: bridging strategic intent with operational excellence.
